How I Stumped ‘Brave’s’ Josh Brolin on Free Speech
Let’s be blunt. Many celebrity interviews are awful.
From “Who are you wearing?” to inane questions like, “In what ways are you like your character?”
It must take great acting just for stars to suppress those eye rolls.
Lately, we’re starting to see interviewers take a more confrontational approach. Are they seeking viral infamy should the stars rebuke them? Or is it simply injecting themselves into the story?
Neither approach is constructive.
There’s another frustration as someone who is both a journalist and a conservative. Many thoughtful questions don’t get asked of today’s big stars. Consider these two examples:
- To George Clooney: You just gave $1 million to the Southern Poverty Law Center. Are you aware of the serious charges that the group slimes decent folk as haters?
- To Leonardo DiCaprio: Your environmental work is impressive, both from a fundraising point of view as well as the documentaries you produce to build awareness. So why isn’t your personal life reflecting that eco-awareness?
- To Jimmy Kimmel: Do you think you’re helping or hurting the country by using divisive language, parroting the talking points of one party and dismissing your critics as “crazies?”
You get the idea. Tough, but fair questions that politically active stars should be prepared to answer.
Only most journalists won’t ask them. Why? It could be that they agree with the celebrities’ left-leaning positions and would rather not challenge them. And, since few entertainment journalists are openly conservative, those questions aren’t asked.
I try to do just that when possible – in a respectable manner, of course.
I used to have greater access to the biggest stars in Hollywood. As a Washington Times employee I interviewed Kevin Spacey, Tom Hanks, Jack Nicholson and many more A-listers. Since moving to Denver that access shrunk. Fewer stars visit the Mile High City during their publicity tours.
They still drop in now and then.
When Jack Black arrived in Denver two years ago to promote “Goosebumps” I asked him if he feared promoting President Obama’s Iran deal could hurt his career. The proposal split the country along ideological lines. What if some Black fans rebelled against his political posturing?
He laughed and said he didn’t give it much thought, even though his agent gently brought up the subject. Fair question. Honest answer. I suspect he hadn’t been asked it before.
A ‘Brave’ Response to a Tough Question
More recently, cast members from “Only the Brave” arrived in Colorado to promote the new film. Josh Brolin, Jennifer Connelly and Miles Teller star in a gritty true story of fire fighters battling Arizona wild fires.
Brolin was one of four “Brave” actors visiting Denver. I read about his background prior to interviewing him and one thing stood out. He’s a straight shooter. So I asked him a question I’ve been dying to ask a major celebrity a long time:
Why aren’t more stars speaking out against the attacks on free speech on college campuses?
RELATED: Why Hollywood’s Silence on Free Speech Matters
I prefaced the question by talking about the current wave of celebrity activism. I mentioned how Brolin’s step mother, Barbra Streisand, often uses her platform to address societal ills. So, given how stars routinely speak up about President Trump, immigration and health care, why aren’t they raising their voices about campuses crushing free speech?
After all, their profession is all about free and open expression.
A blank stare. So I elaborated, talking about how some speakers are harassed on campus and how universities are coughing up thousands of dollars to protect others, like Ben Shapiro, from serious harm.
A long, heavy pause.
“The truth of the matter is I don’t know that much about it,” Brolin said finally. He expounded a bit more, talking vaguely about free speech in a way that was reasonable and smart.
He still didn’t know what I was talking about. He wasn’t being dismissive, distant or disinterested. He genuinely tried to understand my question and answer it in the best way possible.
Here’s a True Free Speech Revelation
“For me it doesn’t affect my business at all so I have nothing at stake … I’m very lucky to have worked in this industry for 33 years, so if it ended tomorrow … I can do anything. I know how to make money. I’ll be fine,” he said. “I don’t really hold this in a place of fear. If I say anything, what will happen to me. I say whatever I feel like saying when I feel passionate about something.”
Brolin proved to be polite and charming throughout the interview, conducted in a roundtable format with four other journalists.
In a way Brolin and I approached the Q&A from our respective bubbles. As a liberty-loving conservative I’m invested in the free speech debate raging in our country. I read every article I can on how colleges are bullying conservatives and refusing to let some of the Right’s brightest minds speak their peace.
Think Shapiro, a former colleague of mine and arguably one of conservatives’ sharpest minds.
RELATED: 7 Reasons ‘No Safe Spaces’ Should Scare Liberals Silly
Brolin, in turn, just wasn’t up to speed on the subject. He could probably weigh in on the nuances of the latest Trump imbroglio or other progressive-friendly topics. Or, for that matters, subjects I have almost no knowledge about. He struck me as an intriguing fellow.
Free speech on campus? Off his radar.
The exchange haunted me for a few days. Part of me hoped Brolin might do a little Googling on the subject as a result of the interview. I also realized once more that my own news feed – a blend of mainstream media bites and conservative news, isn’t what most liberals read.
Did we both walk away with a greater awareness of our differences? Or will we both return to our worldviews?
Looks like it might be an interesting article. Too bad I can’t read it because your stupid adds cover half the screen on my phone.
I really want Hollywood stars to keep their mouths shut. They are not inherently qualified to comment on anything other than films and filmmaking.
I don’t care and don’t want to hear what Josh Brolin thinks about free speech or what Di Caprio thinks about the environment.