Watching director James Cameron’s “Avatar” at home, sans that third dimension, triggers three critical questions.
- Does the film still captivate without that extra dimension?
- Are those clunky lectures still obnoxious on repeat viewings?
- Did Cameron get robbed of a Best Director Oscar?
Yes (especially on Blu-ray). Yes. And … most definitely.
“Avatar” doesn’t need silly glasses to keep us engaged. It’s a breeze to enjoy the film on a purely cinematic level – the crisp narrative and whiz-bang action accented by colors we’ve never seen on screen before.
Cameron can’t let well enough alone.
The film’s strengths (see above) and weakness (a lecture every 15 min.) make watching “Avatar” exasperating at times. Corralling all of the above on screen in a way no one has done before still should have netted him an Oscar.
RELATED: Why Weaver’s Ripley Remains the Ultimate Anti-Mary Sue
“Avatar” takes us to the shimmery world of Pandora, a tribal planet teeming with Unobtainium, an energy source those pesky Earthlings crave. So a private contractor teams up with scientists to infiltrate the planet’s inhabitants, known as the Na’Vi, to find out the best way they can take it.
By force, if necessary.
The company enlists the Avatar program to make it happen, creating artificial Na’Vi bodies and letting humans guide them. A paralyzed Marine named Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) signs up for the program, along with a strong-willed scientist (Sigourney Weaver).
The pair infiltrate the Na’Vi, and Jake makes a connection with Neytiri (Zoe Saldana) that could make his mission a success – or prove he’s gotten too close to the locals.
The action sequences startle with their ferocity, and it’s always a snap to suss out who’s doing what. No shaky cams here, nor does the movement happen so quickly we’re left with a gnawing sense of detachment.
The saga of Jake Sully holds echoes of “Dances with Wolves” as well as Cameron’s environmental activism. But the writer/director can’t let his story exist on its own terms. He jams the script with lines that remind us of the Iraq War, the colonial devastation of Native American tribes and modern battles against terrorism.
And while he isn’t the first director to use science fiction to send a message, his heavy-handed approach is as overwhelming as the visuals.
Terms like “shock and awe,” “fight terrorism with terrorism” and references to martyrdom don’t just rip us out of the story, they simply make little sense.
Cameron stacks the deck here, making the corporate types inhuman and the Na’Vi as peaceful as puppies. The filmmakers’ moral arguments are so naively laid out that they don’t leave an intellectual mark. We’re left to gape at the scenery, the action and the adventure, and while the film delivers on all counts the commentary simply crumbles upon a cursory inspection.
“Avatar” could be the most anti-corporate film ever conceived, and those who dubbed the film “anti-human” are validated by the film’s final image.
A New Official Set Photo from James Cameron’s ‘Avatar’ sequels with producer Jon Landau, Sigourney Weaver, & Joel David Moore…
‘Avatar: The Way of Water’ hits theaters December 2021. pic.twitter.com/PwZXUuaDH2
— DR Movie News 📽 (@DRMovieNews1) April 29, 2020
Worthington’s performance does improve on a second viewing. He’s an act first, think later warrior, but his emotional evolution while living with the Na’Vi is handled with more shading than most blockbusters allow.
And the methods used to create both Jake’s Avatar and Neytiri are even more astounding when seen at home. The facial expressions, aided by motion-capture technology, give complexity and a soulfulness to their expressions, the kind that would have seemed impossible just a few years ago.
“Avatar” represents a quantum leap in visual storytelling that falls back on hackneyed attempts to change hearts and minds about our culture.
DID YOU KNOW: James Cameron pined to make “Avatar” for years, but he feared the technology didn’t exist to make it possible His mind changed, in part, when he saw the CGI character Gollum in “The Lord of the Rings: Two Towers.”