How ‘American Underdog’ Will Surprise Even Die Hard Kurt Warner Fans

The team behind 'I Can Only Imagine' uncorks a mainstream ode to family, faith

We just re-watched Venus and Serena Williams’ improbable rise to tennis stardom via “King Richard.”

Did it matter that their ascent was fresh in mind for most viewers? Of course not. Their story captivated the nation, and “King Richard” shrewdly let their heroics shine.

The same holds true for “American Underdog,” the shocking tale of a grocery store clerk who never stopped dreaming of an NFL career. Hall of Fame quarterback Kurt Warner did much more than that, we now know, but his biopic puts the focus where it belongs.

The Warner family.

Sure, those gridiron heroics are here, but it’s how Warner grew into a man, not merely a gridiron great, that matters.

American Underdog (2021 Movie) Official Trailer - Zachary Levi, Anna Paquin, and Dennis Quaid

Zachary Levi is Kurt, a kid who barely knew his father but bonded with the old man in one key area.


It explains why the strapping teen clung to the sport, long after he should have rightly given up thoughts of a professional career. Sure, he had a cannon for an arm, but he lacked the intangibles that make NFL scouts drool.

Or did he?

He brought that same stubbornness to his love life, especially after meeting a punk-haired gal in a honky tonk. Anna Paquin plays Brenda, a divorced mother of two with a special needs child.

Go away, she told him. I’m no good for you. Kurt begged to differ.

“American Underdog” doesn’t reinvent the sports drama. Instead, the screenplay infuses it with so much heart you’ll think the genre moments are suddenly happening before you in real time. 

Levi occasionally plays up that long, wide-eyed stare when the odds seem impossible, but he captures Kurt’s implacable spirit, self doubt and physicality.

His aching heart, not his character’s arm, powers the film.

Dennis Quaid enters the saga later as Coach Dick Vermeil, offering a fatherly presence Kurt lacked for far too long. They should have had more screen time together, but the movie’s efficient running time might have taken a hit in the process.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by American Underdog (@americanunderdg)

The film delivers the expected reaction shots during the big game. It seems criminal to omit them entirely in a sports drama, but by the third act you’re as invested as the supporting players.

If “American Underdog” feels too perfect to be true, think again. The story’s core beats are part of the Kurt Warner legend.

  • Grocery store clerk
  • Arena Football castaway
  • Cut from the Green Bay Packers (who stuck with some guy named Favre)
  • Natural disaster

It’s how low Kurt sank during those hardships, and how close he came to losing it all, that leaves a mark far greater than any Hail Mary pass.

The movie’s strong supporting cast only heightens the drama, from the reliable Adam Baldwin as Kurt’s college coach to Chance Kelly playing the offensive coordinator who gave Kurt fits.

Directors Jon and Andy Erwin, known for their faith-kissed storytelling (“I Can Only Imagine”), dial down the spirituality this time ’round. Faith plays a supporting role in the Kurt Warner saga, both on and off screen. The biopic laser focuses on family.

Maybe the sports genre template was overdue for a makeover.

HiT or Miss: Need some cinematic uplift, stat? You can’t go wrong with “American Underdog,” a beautifully crafted tale of a soul who refused to give up.

Photo courtesy of Lionsgate

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top button