
“Paper Tigers” looks like artificial Oscar bait on paper.
Three major stars. A throwback New York City setting. Serious themes, including danger, shady business dealings and the Russian mob.
What writer/director James Gray (“Ad Astra”) does with familiar material is anything but phony. His “Paper Tiger” is an exercise in dread, one steeped in sterling performances and character beats that make the impending heartache all too real.
Miles Teller and Scarlett Johansson star as Irwin and Linda Pearl, a happily married couple living an ordinary New York life. They have two teenage sons who squabble like teenage sons do, but otherwise they can’t complain about their lot in life.
Something still nags at Irwin.
He doesn’t have it all, settling for “crappy” when others live it up. Who can’t relate? So when his charismatic brother Gary (Adam Driver) invites him in on a get-rich-quick deal, he agrees.
Said deal involves some shady Russian oil types, and what seemed like a sure thing goes south in a hurry. Now, the Russians are putting pressure on both Gary, a former cop, and Irwin.
Gary downplays the potential danger, but Irwin’s brush with the Russians’ dark side screams otherwise. Meanwhile, Linda experiences some troubling vision issues that open up another sobering subplot.
“Paper Tiger” effortlessly captures late ’80s New York without calling attention to itself. Think oh, so brief radio snippets, picture-perfect set design and a gently washed-out color palette.
That latter nails the film’s sense of impending disaster.
Gray’s cast makes the most of the already absorbing screenplay. Irwin is in awe of his brother, which likely led him to agree to a deal he should have rejected on sight. Teller quietly forecasts that brand of sibling affectin.
Driver’s Gary is full of bluster, a guy who thinks he either has all the answers or can make them up on the fly. That arrogance is fascinating and familiar, and Driver shows how it damaging it can be under the wrong circumstances.
Johansson gets the least meaty role, but her story reveals how cruel life can be even when we play by the rules. She’s the film’s pure heart, one that beats loud and true.
It’s all building to an emotional third act, once capped by a riveting cat-and-mouse hunt. Gray’s precise use of camera angles, sound and extraneous noise makes the sequence as thrilling as a 007 opening.
Only it’s far more deadly.
We’ve seen stories like “Paper Tiger” before, but Gray makes it all feel fresh without diminishing the pain and pathos. The narrative is thrilling when it needs to be, eschewing formulaic cheat codes.
That leaves us wondering when the next shoe will drop. And we know it will.
“Paper Tiger” isn’t an easy watch, putting flesh-and-blood characters in harm’s way. It’s one you cannot turn away from, nor should you.
HiT or Miss: 4 out of 5 stars
Genre: Drama/Thriller/Crime
Runtime: 1 hour, 55 minutes
Where to Watch: In Theaters Nationwide Nov. 20
Family Friendly? R (Adult language, violence and mature themes)